Review: The Silmarillion – Ainulindalë: The Music of the Ainur
Introduction
The Ainulindalë ("The Music of the Ainur") is the opening chapter of J.R.R. Tolkien's The Silmarillion, a work that lays the foundation for the entire mythos of Middle-earth. Often overshadowed by The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit, The Silmarillion provides a rich, ancient history of the world, steeped in divine intervention, creation, and cosmic struggle. In Ainulindalë, Tolkien weaves a tale of the creation of the universe, presenting a cosmic symphony directed by Eru Ilúvatar, the supreme deity of Middle-earth, and performed by the Ainur, the holy spirits. It is a creation myth of extraordinary depth and complexity, and in many ways, it serves as the philosophical heart of Tolkien's legendarium.
Cosmic Origins: The Creation of the Ainur
At the very beginning of the Ainulindalë, Eru Ilúvatar is introduced as the One, the ultimate creator of all things. The Ainur, the holy and powerful spirits, are his first creations. These beings exist beyond the material realm and represent aspects of Ilúvatar’s mind. Their existence is not physical, but rather metaphysical, embodying his wisdom, beauty, strength, and various other traits.
Eru presents the Ainur with a grand vision of the universe. The Ainur are each given the gift of music, a symbolic tool that represents their ability to shape the world through creativity. Each spirit creates its own melody, and through their music, they are able to express their individual powers, personalities, and inclinations. This act of creation through music is not only a literal act of crafting the world but also a symbolic representation of the deep connection between art, thought, and existence in Tolkien’s worldview.
The Great Music: Harmony and Discord
The most striking feature of Ainulindalë is the way Tolkien explores the power of music as a creative force. The Ainur’s music is initially harmonious, reflecting the divine purpose of Eru Ilúvatar. However, the introduction of Melkor, the most powerful of the Ainur, leads to discord. Melkor, desiring to craft his own themes and seeking dominion over the music, introduces a counterpoint that disrupts the harmony. This act of discord mirrors Melkor’s eventual fall from grace and his desire for control, power, and separation from Eru’s design.
The tension between harmony and discord is central to the chapter, representing the eternal conflict between good and evil, order and chaos. Eru Ilúvatar does not intervene directly but allows the Ainur to continue their music, both accepting and correcting the discord. This creates a new and more complex harmony, where the music becomes richer and more nuanced. This idea of good emerging through struggle and conflict is a recurring theme throughout Tolkien’s works.
The Vision of the World: The Creation of Eä
As the music progresses, it takes form, and the vision of the world, known as Eä, begins to emerge. This vision is not a mere reflection of the Ainur’s thoughts, but a fully realized universe, with its physical properties, landscapes, and the potential for life. The world that is created is imperfect and subject to change, which makes it unique within the scope of Eru Ilúvatar’s divine creation.
Eru Ilúvatar reveals to the Ainur that the world they have shaped through their music is to be made real. He bids them enter into it, and the Ainur who are willing to descend into the world do so, becoming the Valar (the Powers of the World) and the Maiar (lesser spirits who serve them). Through their continued influence, the world will grow and evolve, with each of them playing a role in the shaping of history.
This transition from abstract music to tangible creation emphasizes Tolkien’s view of the world as a place of ongoing growth and struggle, where even the divine beings must adapt to the material realm. It also underscores the idea that all things, even the most divine and immortal, are bound to the fate of the world.
Themes and Symbolism: The Role of Free Will and Providence
A central theme in Ainulindalë is the concept of free will versus providence. Eru Ilúvatar, while being the ultimate creator, allows his creations, particularly the Ainur, the freedom to act and influence the world. This freedom leads to both beauty and tragedy, as Melkor’s desire for autonomy leads to the introduction of evil into the world. The tension between destiny and free will is explored in depth, as Melkor’s discordant themes do not disrupt the greater plan of the universe but rather add to its complexity and depth.
This idea is reflective of the larger themes that would later permeate The Silmarillion and Tolkien’s other works, where characters must struggle against their own desires, flaws, and fate. It is through this struggle that true greatness, whether in a hero or a villain, is often revealed. The inclusion of Melkor’s fall is an essential aspect of Tolkien’s moral framework, illustrating how the misuse of power can lead to corruption, yet also highlighting the ultimate victory of the greater good.
Conclusion: A Mythological Foundation
Ainulindalë is a profound introduction to The Silmarillion, setting the stage for the expansive mythology of Middle-earth. Through the use of music, Tolkien offers a poetic and philosophical lens through which to view creation, conflict, and the eternal struggle between good and evil. The Ainulindalë does not just serve as a creation myth but as a theological exploration of free will, destiny, and the interconnection between all beings.
In a broader sense, Ainulindalë encapsulates the essence of Tolkien’s writing: a blending of mythology, philosophy, and language. Its symbolism resonates deeply with readers, offering a timeless reflection on the complexities of creation, the nature of power, and the inevitability of change. It is a story that speaks not only to the creation of a world but to the ongoing creation of meaning itself in the lives of its inhabitants.
In essence, Ainulindalë is the heart of The Silmarillion, a musical expression of Tolkien’s belief in the power of narrative to shape the universe, both in fiction and in the real world. Through its music, the universe of Middle-earth is born, with all its joys, sorrows, triumphs, and tragedies.
- Hits: 7
