Review: Dancing with the Stars – Season 1, Episode 1: Round 1
Introduction
Premiering on June 1, 2005, Dancing with the Stars introduced American audiences to a competitive reality show format that would quickly become a cultural phenomenon. Adapted from the British series Strictly Come Dancing, the show pairs celebrities with professional dancers, who then compete in a series of choreographed ballroom routines. The performances are judged by a panel of experts and scored, with audience votes also playing a crucial role in determining the winners and eliminations.
The first episode, Round 1, serves as the exciting debut of the series, establishing the competition's format, introducing the inaugural lineup of celebrity contestants and their professional dance partners, and setting the stage for a season filled with drama, determination, and dazzling performances.
Plot Summary
The episode begins with host Tom Bergeron introducing the concept of the show, emphasizing the difficulty of ballroom dancing and the challenge faced by the celebrity contestants. Co-host Lisa Canning is also present, offering backstage insights and interviews with the participants.
The premiere showcases the first round of performances, where each celebrity is paired with a professional dancer and must learn a choreographed routine. For this opening episode, the contestants perform either a Waltz or a Cha-Cha, two of the fundamental ballroom styles.
The celebrity lineup for the first season includes:
Trista Sutter (The Bachelorette) paired with Louis van Amstel
Evander Holyfield (boxing champion) paired with Edyta Śliwińska
Joey McIntyre (New Kids on the Block singer) paired with Ashly DelGrosso
Kelly Monaco (General Hospital actress) paired with Alec Mazo
John O’Hurley (Seinfeld actor) paired with Charlotte Jørgensen
Rachel Hunter (supermodel) paired with Jonathan Roberts
Each couple takes to the dance floor, showcasing their first attempts at mastering the elegance of ballroom dance or the lively energy of Latin routines. The performances are scored by the judges, who critique technique, rhythm, chemistry, and overall execution.
The panel of three expert judges consists of:
Len Goodman, a strict and traditional ballroom dance expert
Carrie Ann Inaba, a former dancer and choreographer
Bruno Tonioli, an animated and passionate judge known for his expressive critiques
At the end of the episode, the scores are revealed, giving audiences their first look at how the competition will be structured. However, no one is eliminated in this first round, allowing the contestants to continue training and improving for future performances.
Themes and Analysis
The Challenge of Learning Ballroom Dance
The premiere highlights the steep learning curve faced by celebrities, many of whom have no prior dance experience. The contrast between their first rehearsals and their polished performances on the dance floor illustrates the dedication and hard work required to compete in Dancing with the Stars.
Entertainment and Drama
From the very first episode, the show successfully blends competition with personal storytelling, as contestants share their nerves, struggles, and excitement about stepping out of their comfort zones. The chemistry between partners, the intensity of the judges’ critiques, and the thrill of live performance create a compelling and engaging viewing experience.
The Role of the Judges
The three judges each bring a unique perspective to the show, setting the standard for how performances will be evaluated. Len Goodman emphasizes technical precision, Carrie Ann Inaba focuses on expression and performance, while Bruno Tonioli brings a theatrical flair to his critiques. Their varied feedback adds depth to the competition and helps educate both contestants and audiences about the nuances of ballroom dancing.
Audience Participation
Although scoring is a major factor in determining who advances, the introduction of audience voting ensures that Dancing with the Stars is as much about public appeal and fan support as it is about technical skill. This dynamic makes the show interactive and unpredictable, allowing for surprising eliminations and underdog success stories.
Performances and Production
The production value of the show is immediately impressive, with its glitzy set design, elegant lighting, and dramatic musical cues enhancing the theatrical atmosphere of the ballroom. The live format adds an element of excitement, as there is no room for second takes—contestants must deliver their best performance in the moment.
The choreography by the professional dancers is a standout aspect, as they not only perform but also train their celebrity partners, crafting routines that play to their strengths while challenging them to improve. The costumes, music choices, and staging further contribute to the spectacle, making the show both visually and emotionally engaging.
Strengths of the Episode
Strong Introduction to the Format – The episode effectively establishes the competition’s structure, judging criteria, and participant dynamics.
Diverse Cast of Contestants – The mix of athletes, actors, musicians, and television personalities ensures a wide appeal.
Entertaining and Engaging – The combination of dance, competition, humor, and judge critiques makes for a compelling watch.
High Production Value – The elegant stage, costumes, and live orchestral music elevate the performances.
Emotional and Inspirational – Watching celebrities step outside their comfort zones and embrace the challenge creates genuine moments of triumph and vulnerability.
Weaknesses of the Episode
Limited Dancing Expertise in Early Performances – Since it is the first episode, many contestants are still learning the basics, meaning the performances are not yet at a high level.
Predictable Format – The structure of judge critiques, scoring, and performances follows a routine pattern, which some viewers might find repetitive.
No Elimination in Round 1 – While this allows contestants to improve, it reduces the initial stakes compared to later episodes.
Final Thoughts
As the first-ever episode of Dancing with the Stars, Round 1 successfully introduces the series with a strong mix of entertainment, competition, and emotional storytelling. While some performances feel unpolished due to the contestants' inexperience, the show's charm, production quality, and engaging format make it clear why it would go on to become a long-running hit.
For fans of dance, reality competitions, and feel-good entertainment, this episode is a promising start to a beloved series.
Final Rating: 8/10
- Hits: 23
