Review: The Hobbit – Chapter 4: "Over Hill and Under Hill"
Introduction
Chapter 4 of The Hobbit, titled "Over Hill and Under Hill," marks a transition from the relative safety of Rivendell into the true perils of the journey. As Bilbo and the company attempt to cross the Misty Mountains, they encounter the harsh realities of nature and the dangers that lurk beneath the earth. This chapter is significant as it introduces the goblins, a major antagonistic force in the novel, and sets the stage for Bilbo’s fateful encounter with Gollum in the next chapter.
Beyond its action-packed events, "Over Hill and Under Hill" deepens Tolkien’s themes of fate, the dangers of greed and power, and the contrast between light and darkness. The setting of the Misty Mountains reinforces the idea that the world is vast and dangerous, and the company’s struggles highlight their vulnerability in the face of nature and hostile creatures.
Plot Summary
After leaving Rivendell, Bilbo, Gandalf, and the dwarves begin their arduous journey across the Misty Mountains, where they face harsh weather, including violent thunderstorms. The storm is no ordinary natural phenomenon—it is described as a battle between stone giants hurling boulders at one another, showcasing Tolkien’s blend of mythology and fantasy. The travelers seek refuge in a cave, hoping to rest safely for the night.
However, their respite is short-lived. While the company sleeps, goblins emerge from hidden tunnels and capture them, dragging them into the heart of the mountain. The goblins are cruel and cunning, and their underground lair is a dark, industrial nightmare filled with forges and weapons, reinforcing their characterization as symbols of greed and destruction. Thorin’s sword, Orcrist, is recognized by the goblins as a legendary blade that has slain many of their kind, further building on the theme of history influencing the present.
Just as the goblins prepare to punish the group, Gandalf arrives in a dramatic fashion, using his magic to slay the Great Goblin and rescue the company. With Gandalf leading the way, the adventurers flee through the dark tunnels of the mountain. The chapter ends with them desperately trying to escape the goblins' pursuit, setting the stage for Bilbo’s upcoming solo adventure in "Riddles in the Dark."
Analysis
The Misty Mountains: A Symbol of Danger and the Unknown
The Misty Mountains represent a major threshold in the adventure—crossing them signifies leaving behind any lingering comforts of home or civilization. The storm and stone giants establish the mountains as a realm of chaos and danger, reinforcing the idea that nature itself can be as formidable as the monsters the company faces. This passage through a hostile environment mirrors the classic "descent into the underworld" trope found in mythology, where heroes must navigate perilous depths before emerging wiser or changed.
Tolkien’s description of the mountains emphasizes their ancient, ominous nature, reminding the reader that Middle-earth is filled with forces older and greater than the travelers. The company’s struggles reinforce their smallness in the face of such vastness, making Bilbo’s upcoming personal growth even more significant.
The Goblins: Agents of Greed and Destruction
The goblins in The Hobbit are not just physical threats—they embody industrialization, cruelty, and greed. Their underground lair is filled with forges, weapons, and machinery, contrasting sharply with the natural beauty of Rivendell. This reflects Tolkien’s broader concerns about the loss of nature to mechanization, a theme that would be even more pronounced in The Lord of the Rings.
The goblins' hatred of Orcrist is also significant—it represents an old grudge, reminding readers that Middle-earth’s history is filled with cycles of conflict. This underscores the idea that past actions continue to shape the present, a recurring theme in Tolkien’s works.
Gandalf as the Savior Figure
Gandalf’s timely intervention once again saves the company, reinforcing his role as their protector and guide. His dramatic entrance and the slaying of the Great Goblin highlight his immense power, but also suggest that the company is still heavily reliant on him. This raises the question of whether Bilbo and the dwarves can truly succeed on their own—a question that will be tested in the next chapter.
However, Tolkien ensures that Gandalf’s role does not overshadow the journey’s importance. While he rescues the company, he does not prevent them from experiencing hardship, reinforcing the idea that struggles are an essential part of growth.
Themes and Symbolism
Fate and Luck
Throughout The Hobbit, luck plays a crucial role in Bilbo’s journey, and this chapter continues to highlight this theme. The company’s escape from the goblins is not just due to Gandalf’s power but also to fortuitous timing and the right tools (Orcrist and Glamdring). This aligns with Tolkien’s belief that even small individuals can be carried along by fate, preparing the reader for Bilbo’s own unexpected luck in the upcoming chapters.
Light vs. Darkness
A major symbolic contrast in Tolkien’s work is light versus darkness, and this chapter exemplifies that struggle. The goblins dwell in darkness, while Gandalf’s intervention brings fire and light, emphasizing the power of good over evil. The goblin king’s lair, filled with shadows and malevolence, contrasts sharply with the glowing swords and Gandalf’s magic, reinforcing the idea that evil fears illumination.
The Journey as a Test of Resilience
By this point in the story, Bilbo has faced trolls, harsh weather, and now goblins. Each challenge pushes him further out of his comfort zone, and while he still relies on others for survival, these experiences are shaping him for the greater tests to come. The Misty Mountains serve as a trial of endurance, reminding the company that their quest will not be easy.
Writing Style and Tone
Tolkien’s narration in this chapter shifts in tone, reflecting the ominous and suspenseful atmosphere of the Misty Mountains. His descriptions of the storm, the goblin tunnels, and the company’s peril create a claustrophobic, almost nightmarish setting, immersing the reader in their plight.
Despite the danger, Tolkien still includes moments of humor, particularly in the goblins' exaggerated speech patterns and complaints. This balance between darkness and levity is one of The Hobbit's defining characteristics, ensuring that the story remains engaging for both younger and older readers.
Conclusion
"Over Hill and Under Hill" is a pivotal chapter in The Hobbit, marking the company’s descent into true peril as they cross the Misty Mountains. Through vivid descriptions, thrilling action, and mythological symbolism, Tolkien deepens the sense of adventure while reinforcing key themes such as fate, resilience, and the power of light against darkness.
This chapter also sets the stage for Bilbo’s transformation. While he remains dependent on Gandalf’s aid, his experiences in the goblin tunnels will soon lead him to a defining moment—his encounter with Gollum in "Riddles in the Dark." As the company struggles to escape the goblins, the reader is left with a sense of impending change, knowing that Bilbo’s true test is just around the corner.
- Hits: 13
