Review of Valor (The Faithful and the Fallen, Book 2) by John Gwynne

Introduction

Valor, the second book in The Faithful and the Fallen series by John Gwynne, is an exhilarating continuation of the epic fantasy saga that began with Malice. Published in 2014, this novel elevates the stakes, expands the world, and deepens character development, all while maintaining the gripping storytelling and intense battles that made the first book so compelling. With its themes of loyalty, betrayal, and the eternal struggle between good and evil, Valor firmly establishes Gwynne as a master of modern epic fantasy, drawing comparisons to authors like George R.R. Martin and David Gemmell.

Plot Overview

Valor picks up immediately after the dramatic events of Malice. The Banished Lands are in turmoil, with war raging across the continent as the prophecy of Elyon and Asroth unfolds. Corban, once a blacksmith’s son, is now on the run, grappling with his newfound role as the prophesied Bright Star—destined to stand against the forces of darkness. Meanwhile, Queen Rhin tightens her grip on Ardan, proving to be a cunning and ruthless antagonist, while the forces of darkness under Nathair continue their conquest, believing they are on the side of righteousness.

As the novel unfolds, multiple storylines develop:

• Corban and his allies flee from the forces of Queen Rhin and Nathair, seeking sanctuary while struggling with their roles in the war to come.
• Nathair, manipulated by the treacherous Calidus, continues to believe he is the Bright Star, even as he unwittingly furthers Asroth’s agenda.
• Veradis, Nathair’s loyal first-sword, remains torn between his admiration for Nathair and the increasingly questionable path his king follows.
• Maquin, the warrior bent on vengeance, embarks on a brutal journey that explores themes of revenge and resilience.

Throughout Valor, Gwynne weaves together these storylines, setting the stage for even greater conflicts and revelations to come.

Character Development

One of Gwynne’s greatest strengths is his character work, and Valor significantly deepens the relationships and internal struggles introduced in Malice.

• Corban continues his transformation from a humble boy to a leader, though he struggles with self-doubt and the weight of expectations. His growth is organic and believable, making him one of the most compelling protagonists in modern fantasy.
• Veradis remains one of the most fascinating characters in the series. Though he is on the wrong side of history, his unwavering loyalty and honor make him deeply sympathetic. His gradual realization that he may be serving the wrong cause is a masterful slow burn.
• Maquin steals the spotlight in many of his chapters, offering a gritty and personal revenge story that contrasts with the larger, world-shaping events unfolding elsewhere. His storyline is filled with brutality, perseverance, and unexpected moments of camaraderie.
• Nathair, the supposed hero who is actually the villain, is a fantastic example of a character consumed by ambition and manipulation. His descent into darkness is subtle yet inevitable, making his storyline all the more tragic.
• Rhin, as a villain, is a standout. Cunning, ruthless, and completely in control, she proves to be one of the most formidable antagonists in the series.

With multiple POVs, Gwynne ensures that no character is one-dimensional. Each has their own motivations, doubts, and conflicts, making the novel’s events all the more impactful.

World-Building & Setting

Gwynne expands the world of the Banished Lands significantly in Valor, introducing new locations, cultures, and conflicts that add layers to an already richly detailed setting. From war-torn battlefields to hidden refuges, the novel brings the world to life with a grounded realism that enhances the stakes of the unfolding war.

The use of prophecy and mythology continues to play a crucial role, but Gwynne avoids making it feel predictable or cliché. Instead, he subverts expectations, showing how belief in prophecy can be manipulated by those in power. This adds an element of uncertainty to the narrative, keeping the reader engaged.

The inclusion of animal companions, such as Storm (Corban’s loyal wolven), adds emotional depth and a sense of camaraderie to the story. These creatures are not just symbolic—they play an active role in battles and character relationships, making them an integral part of the world.

Action & Pacing

If Malice was a slow burn that meticulously set up the pieces, Valor is where the war fully ignites. The battles are visceral, intense, and strategically compelling. Gwynne’s combat scenes are some of the best in modern fantasy—gritty, realistic, and emotionally charged. Whether it’s large-scale warfare or one-on-one duels, every fight feels weighty and consequential.

The pacing is faster than Malice, with fewer slow moments and more action-driven storytelling. Each chapter builds momentum, making the novel hard to put down. The stakes are constantly raised, and Gwynne is unafraid to put his characters through hell, ensuring that the reader never feels complacent.

Themes & Symbolism

1. Loyalty vs. Betrayal – Nearly every character in Valor grapples with issues of trust and deception, from Veradis’ blind loyalty to Nathair to Maquin’s personal vendetta.
2. The Nature of Prophecy – The novel explores how prophecy can be both a guiding light and a tool for manipulation, raising questions about fate versus free will.
3. The Cost of War – Gwynne does not romanticize war. Every battle has consequences, and death is permanent. The emotional toll on the characters is palpable.
4. Coming of Age – Corban’s journey is at the heart of the series, showing his growth from a boy into a leader. His struggles with doubt and responsibility make his arc incredibly relatable.

Writing Style

Gwynne’s prose is straightforward yet evocative, balancing description with action seamlessly. His ability to convey emotion through combat, dialogue, and introspection gives Valor an emotional weight that resonates deeply. Unlike some fantasy authors who rely on overly ornate language, Gwynne keeps his writing accessible while still being immersive.

Final Thoughts

Valor is an outstanding sequel that builds upon everything Malice established and raises the stakes in every way. With its unforgettable characters, intense battles, and deeply woven themes, it cements The Faithful and the Fallen as one of the best modern fantasy series.

For fans of epic fantasy looking for a story filled with heart, honor, and brutal warfare, Valor delivers in spades. It is a book that does not just tell a story—it makes you feel every triumph and tragedy alongside its characters.

Rating: 5/5
Pros:
Deep and compelling character arcs
Intense, realistic battle scenes
Rich world-building with a sense of history
Fast-paced, high-stakes storytelling
Emotional depth and moral complexity

Cons:
Some character perspectives might feel slower in comparison to the main plot
The large cast may be overwhelming for some readers

Overall, Valor is a masterfully written novel that improves upon its predecessor in every way. John Gwynne continues to prove that he is a powerhouse in the fantasy genre, and with the way Valor ends, readers will be eager to dive into Ruin, the next installment in this epic saga.