Review: In the Hand of the Goddess (Song of the Lioness Series Book 2)
Introduction
In the Hand of the Goddess is the second installment in Tamora Pierce’s Song of the Lioness series, continuing the adventurous journey of Alanna of Trebond as she navigates the challenges of knighthood while concealing her true identity as a girl. Published in 1984, this novel delves deeper into Alanna’s development as a warrior, her burgeoning magical abilities, and her complex relationships with those around her. As she grows older and faces even more dangerous adversaries, Alanna must reconcile her desire for independence with her evolving emotions and responsibilities.
Building on the strong foundation laid in Alanna: The First Adventure, this sequel introduces darker themes, more intense battles, and deeper emotional conflicts. It explores questions of identity, loyalty, love, and destiny, all while maintaining the fast-paced action and rich world-building that fans have come to love. In this review, we will examine the plot, themes, character development, and Pierce’s narrative style, highlighting why In the Hand of the Goddess remains a beloved classic in young adult fantasy literature.
Plot Overview
In the Hand of the Goddess picks up where the first book left off, with Alanna continuing her training as a squire under Prince Jonathan of Conté. Now older and more skilled, she faces new challenges as enemies from within the kingdom threaten Jonathan’s life and the stability of Tortall. Alanna must navigate court politics, combat intrigue, and confront the dark sorcerer Duke Roger, whose ambitions could destroy the realm.
Early in the story, Alanna encounters the Goddess, who gifts her with a magical amulet that enhances her powers and serves as a protective charm. This divine intervention signifies that Alanna is chosen for a greater destiny, a theme that resonates throughout the book. Meanwhile, she grows closer to Prince Jonathan, developing romantic feelings for him while struggling to keep her true identity a secret.
As Alanna faces the dangers of battle and the complexities of love, she also wrestles with her fear of vulnerability and the consequences of deception. Her growing bond with George Cooper, the King of Thieves, adds emotional depth and complexity to her relationships, creating a subtle love triangle that challenges Alanna’s notions of trust and loyalty.
The climax of the story occurs when Alanna uncovers Duke Roger’s plot to usurp the throne, leading to a dramatic confrontation that tests her courage and skills as a warrior. Forced to reveal her identity as a woman to save the kingdom, Alanna’s journey of self-discovery reaches a critical turning point. The novel ends with her decision to leave court and seek new adventures, setting the stage for the next book in the series.
Themes
Identity and Self-Acceptance
The theme of identity continues to be central to Alanna’s journey. Throughout In the Hand of the Goddess, she struggles with her dual identity as “Alan,” the squire, and Alanna, the young woman beneath the disguise. Her internal conflict reflects her fear of rejection and her desire to be respected for her abilities rather than her gender. As she navigates the expectations placed upon her by society, Alanna learns the importance of self-acceptance and the courage to be true to herself.
Courage and Responsibility
Alanna’s path to knighthood is fraught with danger, requiring her to make difficult choices that test her bravery and sense of duty. Her courage is not only measured by her prowess in battle but also by her willingness to face her own fears and doubts. As she uncovers Duke Roger’s treachery, Alanna learns that courage also means standing up for justice, even at great personal cost. This theme of responsibility is woven throughout the narrative, highlighting the burdens of power and leadership.
Love and Loyalty
The complexity of love and loyalty is explored through Alanna’s relationships with Prince Jonathan and George Cooper. Her growing romantic feelings for Jonathan challenge her sense of independence, as she grapples with her desire for love while maintaining her freedom. At the same time, her loyalty to Jonathan is tested by the secrets she keeps and the political intrigue surrounding them. Alanna’s friendship with George provides a grounding influence, revealing the different forms of love and loyalty that shape her emotional journey.
Destiny and Divine Intervention
The Goddess’s role in Alanna’s life introduces the theme of destiny, suggesting that Alanna’s path is guided by a higher power. The magical amulet serves as a symbol of this divine protection and foreshadows Alanna’s greater purpose in the series. The interplay between fate and free will is skillfully woven into the story, as Alanna struggles to reconcile her personal desires with her destined role as a hero.
Character Analysis
Alanna of Trebond
Alanna’s character development is at the heart of In the Hand of the Goddess. As she matures, she becomes more confident in her abilities while facing the complexities of adulthood. Her emotional growth is evident as she navigates love, friendship, and the moral implications of her choices. Alanna’s struggle with vulnerability and trust makes her a relatable and multidimensional protagonist, whose journey resonates with readers of all ages.
Prince Jonathan of Conté
Jonathan’s character is further explored as he grapples with his responsibilities as the crown prince. His relationship with Alanna deepens, revealing his compassion and loyalty, but also his struggles with leadership and love. Jonathan’s growth as a character is marked by his increasing awareness of the political dangers around him and his willingness to fight for justice.
Duke Roger of Conté
Duke Roger emerges as a powerful antagonist, whose charm and intelligence mask his sinister ambitions. His manipulative nature and mastery of dark magic make him a formidable enemy, driving the novel’s tension and intrigue. Roger’s complexity as a villain adds depth to the narrative, challenging Alanna’s courage and strategic thinking.
George Cooper
George continues to be a steadfast friend and ally, offering emotional support and loyalty to Alanna. His playful charm and unwavering devotion provide a contrast to Jonathan’s royal demeanor, adding complexity to the love triangle dynamic. George’s role as the King of Thieves gives him a unique perspective on power and justice, influencing Alanna’s moral choices.
Style and World-Building
Tamora Pierce’s writing style is vivid and engaging, balancing fast-paced action with deep emotional moments. Her world-building expands in In the Hand of the Goddess, with richer descriptions of Tortall’s political landscape, magical systems, and social hierarchies. The integration of magic, mythical creatures, and historical influences creates an immersive fantasy world that feels authentic and dynamic.
Pierce’s character-driven narrative allows readers to connect with Alanna on a personal level, making her struggles and triumphs emotionally impactful. The dialogue is natural and witty, enhancing the relationships between characters and adding depth to the story’s emotional landscape.
Conclusion
In the Hand of the Goddess is a compelling continuation of Alanna’s journey, filled with adventure, romance, and emotional growth. Tamora Pierce masterfully weaves complex themes of identity, courage, love, and destiny into a narrative that resonates with readers of all ages. Alanna’s strength, vulnerability, and determination make her an inspiring heroine whose story continues to inspire new generations.
With its captivating plot, multidimensional characters, and richly developed world, In the Hand of the Goddess solidifies Tamora Pierce’s place as a pioneer in young adult fantasy literature. This novel not only builds on the promise of its predecessor but also sets the stage for even more thrilling adventures in the Song of the Lioness series. A must-read for fans of fantasy, coming-of-age stories, and tales of courage and self-discovery.
- Hits: 16
